Traditional Worldviews vs. Changing Worldviews in Ireland

-

Overview of Ireland's Dominant Worldview


While Ireland promotes religious freedom in their Constitution, many Irish citizens identify as “Roman Catholic,” which demonstrates the influence of one dominant “worldview” on Irish culture (“Irish Culture,” 2022; Samovar, 2017, p.103). Larry Samovar, author of Communication Between Cultures, asserts that “a culture’s worldview" provides people with a framework to answer "major assumptions about life" (Samovar, 2017, p.104). “Worldview” encompasses a person’s attempt to answer life’s fundamental questions (Samovar, 2017, p.104). For example, about “76%” of “Irish Catholics” accept that “God created the universe” (McGarry, 2012). This belief suggests that some Irish citizens see the basic tenets of Catholicism, such as Jesus’ “resurrection,” as key to understanding their role in the world (McGarry, 2012). Tom Inglis, author of “Church and Culture in Catholic Ireland,” reinforces this notion when he argues that “the majority of people" practice Catholic baptisms, marriages and funerals (Inglis, 2017, 21). This idea demonstrates that “Catholic” values and perspectives on issues, such as death, impact how Irish people choose to live their lives (Inglis, 2017, 21).














Breakdown of Ireland's Religious Affiliations


How Catholicism Impacts Irish Culture, Political and Social Life

Since Catholicism encompasses the dominant “worldview” in Ireland, its principles influence and impact distinct aspects of Irish society (Inglis, 2017, p.22). The Cultural Atlas’ article “Irish Culture,” contends that “the Catholic Church" oversees Ireland's schools and hospitals, which extends their influence into cultural and governmental affairs (“Irish Culture,” 2022). This “role” frames the “Catholic Church” as responsible for many aspects of Irish society (“Irish Culture,” 2022). For example, the New York Times states that the “Catholic Church” controls “97%” of Irish “state-funded primary schools” (Dalby, 2016). This idea implies that the “Catholic Church” oversees the “religious” and secular education of multiple students, which affects how they view certain cultural ideals, such as morality (Dalby, 2016). Raphael Gallagher, author of “Morality in a Changing Irish Society,” reiterates this viewpoint when he asserts that some Irish people base their “moral” decisions on what “the Church wants” (Gallagher, 1981, 714). He suggests that the Catholic Church’s influence directly and indirectly extends to people’s personal lives (Gallagher, 1981, 714). One question remains: does the “Catholic Church” still influence Irish cultural traditions today (Gallagher, 1981, 714).


Influence of the Catholic Church in Ireland
"10 Best Churches to Visit in Ireland"

This link illustrates how the Catholic Church influenced all aspects of Irish life, including architecture. 

How Other Worldviews Influence Irish Culture

Although some in Ireland identify as Catholic, many choose to reject the basic tenants of Catholicism and pursue different worldviews, which creates challenges for intercultural communication (McGarry, 2012; Samovar, 2017, pp.157, 160). The CIA Factbook states that 21.7% of Irish citizens identify as a member of another religion (e.g., “Muslim”) or as non-religious (“Ireland,” 2022). These identifications represent a shift from strict adherence to Catholicism toward greater religious tolerance and diversity (“Ireland,” 2022). For example, “78%” of Irish society chooses to practice their own standards of morality instead of adhering to “Catholic” moral standards (McGarry, 2012). This idea suggests that many Irish citizens are rejecting basic “Catholic” principles and tolerate people deciding their own “worldview[s]” (McGarry, 2012; Samovar, 2017, p.104). However, Douglas Dalby, author of “Catholic Church’s Hold on Schools at Issue in Changing Ireland,” rejects this notion when he claims that “local schools often choose to admit Catholics over non-Catholics” (Dalby, 2016). This “religious preference” in “school admissions” illustrates aspects of Irish society that choose to follow “Catholic” principles at the expense of religious tolerance (Dalby, 2016). The conflict between Catholicism and opposing worldviews exacerbate the tensions between traditional values and changing societies (McGarry, 2012; Samovar, 2017, pp.157, 160).

Catholic Church’s Hold on Schools at Issue in Changing Ireland New York Times

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Cross-Cultural Nonverbal Communication in Ireland

-
Image
  Importance of Understanding Intercultural Communication When people examine Ireland’s culture, they should contextualize Irish nonverbal signals, which benefits intercultural communication (“Ireland Business Culture”). Larry Samovar, author of Communication Between Cultures, asserted that someone should “understand how each situation might influence the meaning given to” nonverbal signals (Samovar, 2017, p.335). This idea framed nonverbal language as signals that people assign meaning to based on cultural values (Samovar, 2017, p.335). For example, when I greet someone from Ireland, I should maintain direct eye contact while shaking their hand and limit “personal displays of affection” (“Etiquette Tips to Know Before Traveling to Ireland,” 2019). This greeting symbolizes trust between me and an Irish citizen, which supplies nonverbal communication “feedback” (“Etiquette Tips to Know Before Traveling to Ireland,” 2019). Samovar reiterated this notion when he claimed that “feedback al
Read more

How Studying Ireland Influences Intercultural Communication

-
Image
  Why I Chose to Study Ireland   I chose to study Ireland because I want to explore how learning about another culture will improve my “intercultural communication” skills (Samovar, 2017, p.19). Milton J. Bennett, author of “Intercultural Communication,” defines this idea as “the study and practice of communication across cultural contexts” (Bennett, 2013). “Intercultural communication” encompasses a person’s attempts to assign “meaning” to “cross-cultural” “communication” (Bennett, 2013; Samovar, 2017, p.13). For example, when I communicate with someone from Ireland, I may judge their culture based on pre-determined behaviors or assumptions, such as an Irish “accent” (Maguire, 2020). These predetermined judgements cause inaccurate “generalizations” about Irish culture, which damages “cross-cultural” “communication” skills (Bennett, 2013; Samovar, 2017, p.19). I can avoid these common pitfalls by understanding how culture influences “communication” styles (Samovar, 2017, p.17). I will
Read more

The Relationship Between Culture and Healthcare Values in Ireland

-
Image
  Irish Cultural Healthcare Practices Ireland’s Healthcare Beliefs: A Fusion of Traditional Values and Modern Medicine   Ireland fuses modern healthcare technology with traditional spiritual remedies, which affects how they prevent and treat illnesses (Heavey, 2019; Specia, 2021). Larry Samovar, author of Communication Between Cultures, asserted that “healthcare providers [should] understand that contemporary healthcare [is multi-faceted]” (Samovar, 2017, p.367). This idea framed healthcare practices as a conflict between modern science and cultural values (Samovar, 2017, p.367). For example, Ireland maintains a mixed public and private healthcare system that allows people to access medical care from doctors based on a “scientific [and] biomedical perspective” (Heavey, 2019; Samovar, 2017, p.369). However, the article titled “A Physical and Spiritual Approach to Healing,” argued that healthcare professionals should consider a “more holistic approach to understanding suffering” (“A
Read more